COP31: IPCC timeline debate puts scientific rigour and equity under scrutiny
Developing countries say a compressed assessment cycle could limit the contribution of Global South research, while others argue that vulnerable nations need the reports in time for the 2028 Global Stocktake
Visual Credits: Paridhi Choudhary
While electrification has dominated the headlines at COP31, another debate has resurfaced during the second week of climate talks in Antalya, Türkiye.
It concerns when the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) should publish its three Working Group reports for the Seventh Assessment Report (AR7), and whether they should be completed in time to inform the second Global Stocktake (GST2) in 2028.
The disagreement has brought two questions into focus. First, how quickly can the IPCC produce its next assessment without compromising the scientific process? Second, whose research and perspectives will be represented in that assessment?
What are the IPCC assessment and the Global Stocktake?
The IPCC and the Global Stocktake are two separate processes under the international climate framework. The IPCC assesses and synthesises scientific research on climate change. Its three Working Groups examine the physical science of climate change (Working Group I), its impacts, adaptation and vulnerability (Working Group II), and mitigation (Working Group III). A Synthesis Report brings together the findings of these reports and other relevant assessments.
The Global Stocktake, on the other hand, is a political process under Article 14 of the Paris Agreement. It takes place every five years and assesses the collective progress countries have made towards the agreement's goals. The first stocktake concluded at COP28 in 2023. The second is scheduled for 2028. Its findings are expected to inform the next round of national climate plans, or nationally determined contributions (NDCs).
IPCC reports provide scientific inputs to the Global Stocktake, but the two processes have different mandates. The dispute is over whether the three AR7 Working Group reports should be completed in time to feed into GST2, or whether the IPCC should follow a longer schedule to allow more time for scientific work and review.
Developed countries, including the European Union, as well as several small island states and least developed countries, want the scientific process to be accelerated so that the reports are available before the stocktake. Some major developing countries, including India, want the Working Group reports to follow a longer schedule, extending into 2029.
India, Russia and Saudi Arabia have been described as science blockers in the debate. But delegates from developing countries argue that they are not blocking the process. They say countries pushing for an accelerated schedule are risking the meaningful participation of scientists and experts from the Global South.
Mary Robinson, the former President of Ireland, said the urgency came primarily from the “least developed countries and the small island states” during a press conference at COP31. She said the expedited timeline was the scientific timeline that countries had agreed upon.
“The [LDCs and island nations] want AR7 before the Global Stocktake. It’s a false premise to say that the [original timeline] is for developing countries. It’s not. The most vulnerable of the developing countries badly want this report because they don’t have the capacity to have separate reports. They rely on this report,” said Robinson.
There is, however, an important distinction in the timeline that countries agreed to at the start of the AR7 cycle. At its 60th session in Istanbul in January 2024, the IPCC agreed that the Synthesis Report would be completed by late 2029, after the three Working Group reports. It did not agree on the individual delivery dates of those reports. Those dates have remained under negotiation.
The next round of sessions for the IPCC is expected to take place virtually in December.
The IPCC debate enters the COP31 cover text
The disagreement over the IPCC's next assessment has also found its way into the proposed COP31 cover decision. The first draft, released on November 16, included three paragraphs recognising the central role of the IPCC, calling for broader participation in its assessment process, and inviting the panel to publish all three Working Group reports and its Synthesis Report in time for the second Global Stocktake in 2028.
One of the paragraphs specifically recognised the need for contributions from Indigenous Peoples, local communities, non-English-speaking regions and developing countries, while allowing sufficient time to prepare comprehensive and credible scientific assessments. This language reflected both sides of the debate: the need to make the assessment available to inform the Global Stocktake and the importance of ensuring that its preparation is inclusive and scientifically robust.
However, the second draft, circulated on November 19, dropped these three specific references to the IPCC's role and the timing of its assessment reports. It retained other references to the panel, including its earlier findings on developed countries' pre-2020 emissions targets and its assessment of carbon dioxide removal. The draft also retained a proposed high-level dialogue on the science of 1.5°C overshoot and the relationship between equity, science and sustainable development.
How the IPCC timeline dispute developed
The disagreement began at the IPCC's 60th session in Istanbul in January 2024, when governments discussed the work programme for the seventh assessment cycle.
They agreed that AR7 would include the three Working Group reports and a Synthesis Report, to be completed by late 2029. But they could not agree on when the three Working Group reports should be published. The Bureau was asked to prepare a schedule for further consideration.
At the next session, in Sofia in July and August 2024, the proposed schedule placed all three Working Group reports in 2028. This would allow them to feed into the second Global Stocktake.
India, China, Saudi Arabia and other developing countries raised concerns about the time available for research, author selection and government reviews. They argued that the proposed schedule could limit the availability of new research from developing countries and place additional pressure on their smaller teams of scientists and government experts. The disagreement continued, and the Panel deferred a decision.
At the 62nd session in Hangzhou in February 2025, governments approved the outlines of the three Working Group reports but again failed to agree on their schedule. India proposed a staggered timeline, with Working Group I completed in 2028 and Working Groups II and III in late 2028 and 2029. The proposal was intended to allow more time for the reports dealing with climate impacts, adaptation and mitigation. The Panel deferred the workplan again.
The disagreement continued at the 63rd session in Lima in October 2025 and the 64th session in Bangkok in March 2026. At the latter, India and other countries pushed for a formal discussion of the timeline and argued that the schedule needed to account for the time required for government reviews and participation by developing-country experts. The issue remained unresolved.
At the 65th session in Addis Ababa in October 2026, governments narrowed the proposals to four options but could not reach consensus. The session was suspended and is scheduled to resume virtually in December.
The debate has therefore continued through five IPCC sessions over nearly three years. It is not simply a disagreement over a publication date. It concerns the time available to produce new scientific literature, select authors, review draft reports and allow governments to assess their findings.
In reality, the issue is more nuanced than a simple division between countries that want faster climate action and those that want to delay it. Developing countries say they want due diligence to be followed instead of rushing the reports. This requires time for the production, synthesis and review of scientific literature.
“It is not possible to squeeze the entire work of 8 years within 5 years. The robustness and comprehensiveness of scientific studies should not be compromised in haste,” said a delegate with knowledge of the negotiations.
Another issue is the question of equity in science. Delegates argue that a large share of climate research is produced by universities and institutions in the Global North, while research from the Global South remains underrepresented.
“The longer timeline allows more representative research from the Global South to appear. Global South researchers also face difficulty in publishing peer-reviewed papers in these places. You can't compromise on equity in science,” they said.
But Laurence Tubiana, the CEO of the European Climate Foundation, told CarbonCopy that she does not agree with this argument and called it a “narrative”.
“It’s a political enterprise, not a scientific positioning,” she said.
According to her, the contributions of scientists from the Global South are central and aligning the publication of all three reports before the Global Stocktake is important.
“For the small islands and least developed countries, which have very little resources, more resources need to be mobilised,” she said.
Is climate science unequal?
Climate science is often presented as a neutral guide to the choices governments must make to limit global warming.
But back in 2023, after the completion of IPCC’s AR6 cycle, CarbonCopy reported that the models used to develop possible climate and energy pathways, and assessed by the IPCC in its AR6, rely on assumptions about economic growth, energy use, technology and the cost of cutting emissions. Researchers have questioned whether these assumptions adequately account for countries' different starting points, historical responsibilities and development needs.
Some IPCC mitigation pathways, scientists told CarbonCopy, require developing countries to make steep cuts in coal use while allowing richer countries more time to reduce oil and gas consumption. Others project that large gaps in income and energy use between rich and poor countries will persist for decades. These findings have raised questions about whether the assumptions underlying the pathways adequately reflect equity and countries' different development needs.
Here are some of the main issues scientists highlighted to CarbonCopy:
Some climate pathways place steep demands on coal use in developing countries
A 2023 study published in Nature, led by Greg Muttitt of the International Institute for Sustainable Development, questioned the balance of emissions reductions in IPCC mitigation pathways. It found that the pathways required coal-fired power generation in countries such as China, India and South Africa to decline at a rate twice as fast as any historical reduction achieved by a power technology in any country.
The study argued that more realistic pathways would require the Global North to cut emissions 50% faster, with much deeper reductions in oil and gas use. Muttitt warned that an excessive focus on coal phase-outs could create the impression that developing countries must shoulder a larger share of mitigation.
The economics used in models can overlook the costs faced by developing countries
The IPCC assesses pathways generated by integrated assessment models (IAMs), which examine possible future energy and climate scenarios. These models often prioritise the least-cost route to reducing emissions. But this approach can overlook the political and financial conditions in which countries must make the transition.
Aayushi Awasthy, an energy economist and researcher at the University of East Anglia, explained that a model might show that setting up a wind farm in India is relatively cheap without accounting for the practical difficulties of building it. The models may also fail to capture the cost and availability of capital, even though clean energy financing in developing countries can cost up to seven times more than in the US or Europe.
The models do not adequately account for historical responsibility
Aljoša Slameršak, a researcher at the Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, argued that integrated assessment models struggle to produce genuinely equitable emissions pathways because that would require high-income countries to reach net zero much sooner.
High-income countries have contributed a disproportionate share of historical emissions and continue to account for a large share of current emissions. But because steep reductions in rich countries are often considered politically or practically difficult, models can end up distributing the mitigation burden according to economic efficiency rather than historical responsibility.
The models can shift the burden of carbon removal to the Global South
Tejal Kanitkar, associate professor at the National Institute of Advanced Studies, explained that the emphasis on cost-effectiveness in climate models can encourage greater reliance on land-based carbon removal. Because afforestation is assumed to be relatively cheap in developing countries, some IPCC pathways place a substantial share of future carbon sequestration in the Global South. This can also increase reliance on technologies such as bioenergy with carbon capture and storage, with implications for land use, food systems, water and biodiversity.
The models can preserve development inequalities for decades
A study by researchers at the National Institute of Advanced Studies and the M.S. Swaminathan Research Foundation examined 556 scenarios from the IPCC's Sixth Assessment Report. It found that the scenarios projected substantial differences in per-capita income and energy consumption between developed and developing countries, extending to 2050.
Tejal Kanitkar pointed out that some scenarios project per-capita energy consumption in North America to be five times that of South Asia and six to eight times that of sub-Saharan Africa in 2050. She questioned how countries in these regions could achieve their development goals if their energy consumption remained so far below that of wealthy countries.
The study also found that the scenarios place more than 65% of projected carbon sequestration in developing countries. Kanitkar's broader argument was that the models do not simply overlook global inequality. They often assume that existing inequalities will continue for decades.
The problem is not just what models calculate, but how policymakers use them
Muttitt cautioned that IPCC pathways are often used uncritically as policy guides, even though they are based on assumptions that may not reflect the political and economic realities of different countries. He noted that researchers working in Europe may be more familiar with the difficulties of electrifying transport in their own countries than with the barriers to replacing power infrastructure in the Global South. This can influence which constraints receive attention in global models.
Awasthy made an important distinction here. Integrated assessment models do not claim to produce fair outcomes. They aim to identify the cheapest route to mitigation, often under an assumption that a single global authority is responsible for emissions reductions. Such models can provide useful insights, she said, but their findings cannot dictate the actions of developing countries.
With additional inputs from Rishika Pardikar’s report for CarbonCopy in 2023