COP31: Carbon removal gains ground as concerns grow over climate overshoot

As carbon removal enters the COP31 negotiations, scientists and civil society groups warn that relying on unproven technologies to bring temperatures back down could distract from the urgent need to cut emissions.

By Shaswata Kundu Chaudhuri17 Nov. 2026
COP31: Carbon removal gains ground as concerns grow over climate overshoot

Visual Credits: Arkatapa Basu


The crisp 19°C air of the Mediterranean town of Antalya, Turkiye, seems almost forgetful of the scorching summer that singed Europe just this year. While the world is on course to breach the critical 1.5°C threshold, the official negotiating process at COP seems to have accepted it.

On November 13, the COP31 Presidency released an informal summary note from initial consultations that includes carbon dioxide removal (CDR) as a potential element of this year’s cover decision.

In other words, the possibility of letting the global average temperature breach the threshold and then be brought down is being actively considered. 

“Instead of the implementation COP, there is a real danger of COP31 becoming the Overshoot COP,” said Mary Church, Geoengineering Campaign Manager at the Center for International Environmental Law (CIEL) during a press conference at COP31. She added that there was active reframing of the climate conversation of managing the overshoot instead of acting to stop it.

There are inherent dangers to this. Firstly, the efficacy, affordability and scalability of the technologies — like carbon capture and storage and direct air capture — that fall under CDR’s umbrella is one to examine. Secondly, the peddling of these technologies as solutions can mask the immediate need of removing carbon emissions at source, according to scientists and civil society experts.

 

 

This raises the bigger question of whether this gives a free hand to major polluters to continue emitting as they are until the future abatement? And who bears the growing costs of the climate crisis in the meantime?

The question of equity

“Gambling on CDR to manage overshoot and return the world to 1.5 is a highly risky strategy. These technologies simply do not exist at any meaningful scale like what would be needed to have a real impact on the climate,” said Church, adding that these technologies are also subject to a long-standing moratorium under the Convention on Biological Diversity because of the grave risks they pose to biodiversity. 

But there is support from the developed world. For example, the European Union (EU) supports CDR technologies as a means to achieve net zero in its longer term strategy, planning for a temporary overshoot of 1.5°C, followed by a subsequent return by the end of the century. This was laid out by the EU Council before COP.

According to observers from the International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD), some Parties proposed accelerating the research, development, and deployment of CDR and CCUS as a ‘concrete solution’. 

But developing nation blocs like the G77 and China have always maintained the position that developed nations have to take the lead in rapidly cutting emissions, due to their historical responsibility. Parallely, they’ve negotiated for technology and finance transfer for accelerating decarbonisation in their own economies, according to their 2026 ministerial statement.

But the fallouts from implementing such technologies are not equitably distributed. Large-scale monoculture plantations, developed to generate carbon credits, can lead to land grabbing, forced displacement, water pollution and the loss of farmland and grazing areas, said Kwame Kponzo of the Global Forest Coalition. 

The increasing portrayal of nuclear power as a zero-carbon solution was also challenged by Soumya Dutta of Friends of the Earth India. According to him, nuclear power deployment contains embedded emissions through the life cycle of the power source - from extracting and mining of the uranium to the disposal of hazardous waste after its usable period. “New nuclear plants take years to build, locking resources and emissions into infrastructure at precisely the moment when rapid action is required,” he said. 

As negotiations continue, the debate over carbon removal is ultimately about more than technology. For communities already facing the consequences of a warming planet, promises of future removals cannot replace emissions cuts today.

 

[Edit: Bhasker Tripathi, Production: Arkatapa Basu]

Share

LinkedInXFacebook

About the Author

Shaswata Kundu Chaudhuri

Shaswata Kundu Chaudhuri

Shaswata writes about the environment at the intersection of technology, energy, finance and mobility.
See Author's Posts