COP31 final text: No transition away from fossil fuels, no $120 billion adaptation finance target, includes “35 by 35”electrification and CCUS
Visual Credits: Flickr
The COP31 published its delayed third draft“cover decision” carrying 94-paragraphs down from a 144-paragraph first draft.
The new draft has no explicit reference on the target to triple adaptation finance (to $120 b), leaves out transition away from fossil fuels and no clear timelines for the next IPCC report. It still includes “35 by 35” electrification target and most controversially includes giga tonne scale CCUS deployment target.
The 35% global electrification target is not directly linked to efforts to triple renewable energy capacity by 2030 and double the global average annual rate of energy efficiency improvement by 2030, as it was in the November 19 draft. This could end up adding to existing energy systems instead of replacing costly, inefficient oil, gas, and coal.
The final draft calls for accelerating carbon capture, utilisation and storage (CCUS) deployment, with an aim of reaching gigatonne scale globally by 2035 as a collective aspiration, particularly in hard-to-abate sectors. This replaces the quantified deployment options of 500 million tonnes and 1.3-2.5 gigatonnes included in the earlier draft. Accelerating CCUS has been seen as done to balance out parties opposed to inclusion of global “35% by ‘35” electrification target which Arab countries opposed saying that the cover decision should not target any fuels or sectors. But they also want the inclusion of CCUS in the text. Experts point out that the “u” in CCUS could be taken to include “enhanced oil recovery”, where captured CO2 is pumped into wells to extract more oil.
‘Worst COP ever’
The European Union blocked inclusion of adaptation finance targets sought by developing countries. The EU’s climate commissioner Wopke Hoekstra told Bloomberg the bloc would be offering no new money during the negotiations, describing any demands for such funding as “dead in the water” and effectively ending the conversation before it began. Developing countries, meanwhile, have not been willing to bend on what they see as basic questions of justice. In the closing hours of the negotiations, the Climate Action Network (CAN) called a press conference to denounce the European Union as obstructionist, and damn COP31 as “the worst COP ever.”
“When you come into a COP and a commissioner of a very important regional bloc says we are not coming with any finance, finance is ‘dead in the water’—think about that,” Tasneem Essop, CAN executive director, told Drilled. “For us in the Global South, death in the water is very literal. So it’s a shameful way to come to a COP where we are going to be fighting for adaptation finance to protect people from being dead in the water,” the outlet reported, adding that while trillions are needed for adaptation, the total money pledged to adaptation finance at COP31 amounted to $50 million. Tasneem said that was half the cost of an F-35 Lightning fighter jet.
“We’re not even going to measure that $50 million in relation to the $3 trillion that rich nations are spending on wars, a genocide, and conflicts across the world,” Essop added.
The outlet noted that no one wants countries to walk away from the negotiations. Multilateralism cannot be allowed to fail, but parties must fight for a better outcome.